Sometimes simple really is the best. On a quaint little corner of a street in a small New Jersey town sits an Italian restaurant with unassuming signage that reads Pasta Shop. Inside you’ll find a modest, inviting restaurant serving up homemade Italian fare that’s so good you’d be willing to hop on the Garden State Parkway for one of their warm, inviting meals. With a pared-down menu of Italian classics offered to guests on a first-come, first-serve basis, this spot simply hits the spot. But don’t let any of this simplicity fool you. The Pasta Shop, just 35 miles west of New York City in Denville, NJ was just named Yelp’s best pasta restaurant in the country! And it’s well deserved. Executive chef and co-owner Tommy Pollio has honed his skills in kitchens across the country, but it was his dream to share his craft and passion with those closest to him in his hometown. We spoke to Pollio just after Yelp’s top 100 list came out about all things pasta, perfect portions and more.
Congrats on being named as Yelp’s #1 pasta spot in the country. That is no small feat! What has the response been like since then? Has it been overwhelming? What’s surprised you the most?
The recognition has been amazing. With so many talented chefs and pasta makers across the country, it’s incredible to be included among them. I was totally surprised when I received the email from Yelp congratulating me on the morning the article was released.
You also grabbed a spot on the USA Today’s 2026 restaurants of the year list. Clearly you’re doing something right. What is the most satisfying part of these recognitions?
For me, the most rewarding part is seeing the years of hard work and dedication getting some recognition. Running a restaurant is a collective effort, and none of these accomplishments would be possible without the amazing people I have the privilege of working alongside everyday. It’s also really special to see a small independent neighborhood restaurant receive national attention. Our goal has always been to make great food and take care of our guests. Knowing that resonates with people beyond our local community is incredibly gratifying.
I took a look at your menu and it’s obvious that you keep things pretty simple with the offerings: 6 pastas, 3 entrees, and a handful of antipastos to select from. Is the theory of “less is more” true here?
Absolutely. I’ve always believed that it’s better to do a handful of things exceptionally well than try to offer an extensive menu. Our menu is small and intentionally focused. This gives us the flexibility to offer daily or weekly specials that reflect the seasons and the best ingredients and products available. Simplicity isn’t about doing less work. It’s about putting more thought and care into what we choose to focus our energy on.

Chef Pollio recommends the mozzarella sticks, a crowd favorite.
Let’s go back to the beginning. How did The Pasta Shop come about? What did you envision in setting out to create the restaurant?
I’d spent years living and working in different cities across the country, including Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Chicago. During that time I was learning my craft and developing my own identity as a chef. When I returned home to New Jersey I wanted to create a casual neighborhood restaurant centered around fresh pasta, and Italian-American classics. My vision was to share my expertise with the community where I grew up. I wanted to make food approachable, accessible and fun, without white tablecloths or pretentiousness. Real honest food in a comfortable environment, where everyone feels welcome.
Did you have a model that you looked to for inspiration, or a restaurant that you envisioned this after?
I’ve been fortunate to experience so many great restaurants and concepts throughout my career and they’ve all influenced me in different ways. But rather than trying to re-create someone else’s vision, I wanted to build something with an identity entirely it’s own. At The Pasta Shop you can watch the fresh pasta being made in the front window, feel the energy of the staff moving throughout the restaurant, hear the clatter of the open kitchen, the conversations and laughter of guests, and the sound of rock n roll playing in the background. It all comes together to create an atmosphere that’s lively, welcoming and uniquely ours, packed into a small space that has thankfully become special to so many people.
To start an Italian restaurant in New Jersey is one thing. To start one that stands out is a real accomplishment. What is your background? What brought you to Denville?
I was born and raised in Denville, so my connection to this community goes way back. After cooking for a couple years in Chicago, I decided to return home. Today, I’m fortunate to be raising my family here while operating a business in my hometown, and there’s something really special about that. Denville is an incredible community and being able to contribute to it both personally and professionally means a great deal to me.
What is the secret to the best pasta? What sets The Pasta Shop apart and earned you that #1 ranking by Yelp?
Great pasta starts with quality ingredients, proper technique and a genuine love for what you’re doing. But I think what really separates a good restaurant from a great one is consistency. Making an exceptional dish is one thing, but being able to deliver that same level of quality day after day while providing great customer service for our guests is something entirely different. Our staff portions every order of pasta before its ever cooked or served, so each order is exactly the same. This is just one small example of what we do behind the scenes, and there are dozens of these things we do on a daily basis. We put a tremendous amount of effort into the details and we’re constantly adjusting and looking for ways to improve. I think that commitment to consistency, quality, and hospitality has been the foundation of our success.
Do you have any future plans to expand, or change things here at The Pasta Shop?
We don’t currently have plans to expand. I’ve never subscribed to the idea that more automatically means better. We’re proud of what we’ve created and our focus is on continuing to refine and improve it. Restaurants are constantly evolving, and I think it’s important to embrace that. My ethos has always been to improve everyday, whether it’s developing new dishes, adjusting on our processes, or finding better ways to serve our guests. We’re always working toward becoming a better version of ourselves. I do have an exciting new Pasta product that I’ve spent years developing, which I will be launching soon. It’s a project I’m really passionate about and I’m looking forward to sharing more about it soon.
What can diners expect when they come to The Pasta Shop?
We’re a small neighborhood restaurant with 24 seats so things can get pretty busy. For dine in, once all the seats are full, we quote you an approximate wait time and send you a text message when your table is ready. If the wait is longer than you would like, takeout is a great option, which guests can enjoy at the picnic tables along First Avenue, across the street at Diamond Spring Brewery, or in the comfort of their own home. Above all, guests can expect friendly, welcoming service and thoughtfully prepared food made with high-quality ingredients. Everything is cooked to order and we work hard to offer an experience that feels special without being expensive or intimidating. Our goal is simple: great food, genuine hospitality, and exceptional value.

Ziti Norcina with homemade sausage.
If I’m coming here for the first time, what should I order?
Our homemade mozzarella sticks have become a signature appetizer and they’re a favorite among both kids and adults. For pasta, you really can’t go wrong with our Rigatoni alla Vodka or Pappardelle Bolognese. Both are great introductions to what we do. Definitely save room for dessert. Our classic cannoli are light, crisp and just sweet enough to be the perfect ending to your meal. We also feature daily specials, so I always encourage guests to check out our Instagram page to see what we’re working on.
What’s the #1 dish on the menu?
That really depends on the season, which is one of the things I love most about cooking. During the summer months our Sweet Corn Ravioli is one of our most popular dishes. It’s a great example of taking a beautiful seasonal ingredient and allowing it to shine. In the colder months of the year, our Ziti Norcina with Homemade Sausage is the favorite. It’s rich, comforting and exactly the kind of dish you want on a chilly New Jersey evening.
NEXT ON THE DISH