Unlike many other shots, this is one you’d probably rather sip and savor instead of shooting straight back. At Portland’s haunted manor-themed bar, the menu is rife with inventive cocktails and shots, among them, the Butter Beer Shot. This spin on Harry Potter’s favorite libation is made with vanilla Smirnoff, Butterscotch Schnapps, and cream soda, all topped with whipped cream. The cute mini drink comes in a tiny glass mug and tastes just how you’d envision Hogsmeade’s butterbeer to truly taste. It’s creamy, candy-like, but not too overwhelmingly sweet. It’s the perfect nightcap for a magical evening.